The Sanctuary: Homes for Sale on Catawba Island

The Sanctuary at a Glance

Location: N Sanctuary Dr near the Catawba Island Club, Port Clinton, OH 43452
Streets: N Sanctuary Dr
Property type: Single-family homes
Year built: 1963 (only recorded sale)
Home size: About 1,540 sq ft (only recorded sale)
Bedrooms: 3 (only recorded sale)
HOA: About $600/year (most recent listing)
Waterfront: Lagoon and marina setting
School district: Port Clinton City Schools
Recent sales: $887,500 (1 sale, Oct 2023–Oct 2026)
Sales and community data: Firelands MLS.

Overview

The Sanctuary is a small neighborhood on N Sanctuary Drive near the Catawba Island Club. Homes here rarely reach the MLS: Firelands MLS shows a single sale over the past ten years, at $887,500 in 2026.

Homes & Features

  • Lagoon and marina setting
  • Close to the Catawba Island Club
  • Small annual association fee
  • Listings are rare, so off-market inquiries are worth making
  • Ask us about homes or lots coming up for sale

Community & Location

The Sanctuary is close to the Catawba Island Club, its golf course and marina, and a short drive from the Miller Ferry dock to Put-in-Bay and Middle Bass.

Schools

The Sanctuary is served by Port Clinton City Schools, including Port Clinton High School. Confirm individual school assignments with the district.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do homes in The Sanctuary sell for?

Firelands MLS shows one sale over the past ten years, at $887,500 in 2026. With so few sales, ask us for a current value estimate.

Does The Sanctuary have an HOA?

Yes. The most recent listing shows an association fee of about $600 per year.

Is The Sanctuary on the water?

The most recent listing was coded as lagoon, lake and marina frontage. Ask us about water access for a specific lot.

How can I buy in The Sanctuary if nothing is listed?

Tell us what you’re looking for. We can reach out when a home or lot is about to come up for sale.

What school district is The Sanctuary in?

The Sanctuary is in the Port Clinton City School District.

Get in Touch

Contact the Vacationland Ohio Team for current availability or a private showing in The Sanctuary.

Browse all Catawba Island communities