Island Club: Cottage Homes for Sale on Put-in-Bay

Island Club at a Glance

Location: Off Sandcastle Dr, Windward Way and Leeward, South Bass Island, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Streets: Sandcastle Dr, Windward Way, Leeward, Mariners Cove, Starboard Trl
Property type: Single-story cottage homes, many manufactured, plus a few condos
Year built: 1992–1996
Home size: About 1,040–1,350 sq ft
Bedrooms: 3
HOA: About $5,600/year (about $467/month) in recent listings (association management, common ground, insurance, landscaping, lawn care, pool, water, sewer, trash and snow removal)
Amenities: Community pool; wooded cul-de-sac setting near the Lake Erie Islands Nature & Wildlife Center (per listings)
School district: Put-in-Bay Local Schools
Recent sales: $245,000–$315,000 (4 sales, Oct 2023–Oct 2026)
Sales and community data: Firelands MLS.

Overview

Island Club is a planned community of single-story cottage homes on Put-in-Bay, with about 11 sales on Firelands MLS over the past ten years. Every home sold had three bedrooms and about 1,040 to 1,350 square feet, many are manufactured homes, and the association fee covers the pool, grounds, water and sewer. Many Island Club homes are rented to island visitors.

Homes & Features

  • Three-bedroom, single-story cottage homes built from 1992 to 1996
  • About 1,040 to 1,350 square feet
  • Many manufactured homes; check how each home is titled and financed
  • Community pool
  • Fee covers water, sewer, trash, lawn care and the pool

Community & Location

Island Club is on the south side of South Bass Island in a wooded setting, a short golf-cart ride from downtown Put-in-Bay, South Bass Island State Park and the Lake Erie Islands Nature & Wildlife Center. The Miller Ferry runs from Catawba Island to Put-in-Bay and Middle Bass, the Jet Express carries passengers from Port Clinton, and island air service flies from Port Clinton.

Schools

Island Club is served by Put-in-Bay Local Schools, the K–12 school on South Bass Island. Confirm current details with the district.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do homes in Island Club sell for?

Recent Firelands MLS sales in Island Club from October 2023 to October 2026: $245,000–$315,000. There were about 11 sales over the past ten years. Ask us for a current value estimate.

Is there an HOA in Island Club?

About $5,600/year (about $467/month) in recent listings (association management, common ground, insurance, landscaping, lawn care, pool, water, sewer, trash and snow removal).

When were homes in Island Club built?

Homes were built 1992 to 1996 and range from about 1,040–1,350 sq ft.

Are Island Club homes manufactured homes?

Many are. Listings show a mix of manufactured and site-built homes, so check how each home is titled and financed, since that can affect your loan options and insurance.

What school district is Island Club in?

Island Club is in the Put-in-Bay Local School District.

Get in Touch

Contact the Vacationland Ohio Team for current availability or a private showing in Island Club.

Browse all Put-in-Bay communities