Catawba Orchard Beach: Homes for Sale on Catawba Island

Catawba Orchard Beach at a Glance

Location: Northwest Catawba Island near NW Catawba Rd, Port Clinton, OH 43452
Streets: E Overlook Dr, NW Catawba Rd area
Property type: Single-family homes
Year built: 1989–2006 (recent sales)
Home size: About 940–3,200 sq ft
Bedrooms: 3–5
HOA: About $400–$600/year (common ground and snow removal)
School district: Port Clinton City Schools
Recent sales: No sales Oct 2023–Oct 2026; 2 sales $270,000–$468,333 over the past ten years
Sales and community data: Firelands MLS.

Overview

Catawba Orchard Beach is a small lake community on the northwest side of Catawba Island. Homes here rarely reach the MLS: Firelands shows only two sales over the past ten years, the latest in 2022.

Homes & Features

  • Single-family homes of about 940 to 3,200 square feet
  • Three to five bedrooms
  • A quiet setting on the island’s northwest side
  • Listings are rare, so off-market inquiries are worth making
  • Small annual association fee

Community & Location

Catawba Orchard Beach is a short drive from the Miller Ferry dock, Gem Beach and the Catawba Island Club. Downtown Port Clinton is about 15 minutes south.

Schools

Catawba Orchard Beach is served by Port Clinton City Schools, including Port Clinton High School. Confirm individual school assignments with the district.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do homes in Catawba Orchard Beach sell for?

There were 2 Firelands MLS sales in Catawba Orchard Beach over the past ten years, from about $270,000 to $468,333, and none from October 2023 to October 2026. Listings here are rare, so ask us for a current value estimate.

Does Catawba Orchard Beach have an HOA?

Yes. Listings show an association fee of about $400 to $600 per year for common ground and snow removal.

When were homes in Catawba Orchard Beach built?

Homes were built from about 1989 to 2006 in recent sales and range from about 940 to 3,200 square feet.

How can I buy in Catawba Orchard Beach if nothing is listed?

Tell us what you’re looking for. We track this area and can reach out when a home is about to come up for sale.

What school district is Catawba Orchard Beach in?

Catawba Orchard Beach is in the Port Clinton City School District.

Get in Touch

Contact the Vacationland Ohio Team for current availability or a private showing in Catawba Orchard Beach.

Browse all Catawba Island communities