Bay Haven Estates: Johnson’s Island Homes for Sale in Marblehead

Bay Haven Estates at a Glance

Location: Memorial Shoreway and Confederate Dr on Johnson’s Island in Sandusky Bay, Danbury Township, Marblehead, OH 43440
Streets: Memorial Shoreway, Confederate Dr
Property type: Single-family homes
Year built: 1964–2006
Home size: About 1,310–3,110 sq ft
Bedrooms: 2–5 (most 3)
HOA: About $500–$525/year in recent listings; some homes show no fee
Waterfront: Sandusky Bay views on most listings; boat dockage owned with about half
School district: Danbury Local Schools
Recent sales: $325,000–$1,125,000 (9 sales, Oct 2023–Oct 2026)
Sales and community data: Firelands MLS.

Overview

Bay Haven Estates is a Sandusky Bay neighborhood on Johnson’s Island, a private residential island reached by a toll causeway from the Marblehead Peninsula, with about 32 sales on Firelands MLS over the past ten years. Most homes have bay views and about half come with boat dockage.

Homes & Features

  • Single-family homes built from the 1960s to the 2000s
  • About 1,310 to 3,110 square feet, most with three bedrooms
  • Sandusky Bay views from most homes
  • Boat dockage owned with about half of the homes sold

Community & Location

Bay Haven Estates sits along Memorial Shoreway on Johnson’s Island, next to Bay Cliffs; the island’s toll causeway connects to Bayshore Road on the peninsula. Lakeside and Marblehead are about 10 minutes north, and the Route 2 bridge to Sandusky and Cedar Point is about 15 minutes west.

Schools

Bay Haven Estates is served by Danbury Local Schools, the district for Lakeside, Marblehead and Danbury Township. Confirm individual school assignments with the district.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do homes in Bay Haven Estates sell for?

Recent Firelands MLS sales in Bay Haven Estates from October 2023 to October 2026: $325,000–$1,125,000. There were about 32 sales over the past ten years. Ask us for a current value estimate.

Is there an HOA in Bay Haven Estates?

About $500–$525/year in recent listings; some homes show no fee.

When were homes in Bay Haven Estates built?

Homes were built 1964 to 2006 and range from about 1,310–3,110 sq ft.

What school district is Bay Haven Estates in?

Bay Haven Estates is in the Danbury Local School District.

Get in Touch

Contact the Vacationland Ohio Team for current availability or a private showing in Bay Haven Estates.

Browse all Marblehead & Lakeside communities